Why Are People Bicycling on This Street?
This article, which is part two of a three-part series, was originally published in the Montecito Journal, June 29–July 6, 2023. It, along with an added introduction from the author, is shared here with permission. Read part one here and part three here.
Santa Barbara, California, closed its main commercial corridor, State Street, to cars due to the pandemic in 2020. This opened its full width to pedestrians and cyclists. Since the closure, the city formed the State Street Advisory Committee to create a long-term plan for downtown, including the layout of State Street. One of the committee’s main concerns is if the street should remain closed to vehicles, and how or if bikes should be incorporated into the design. Below, I argue that bikes and pedestrians are an essential part of downtown culture and business growth and need to be put at the forefront of any design. —Sullivan Israel
Bicyclists on State Street. (Source: Author.)
At the last State Street Advisory Committee (SSAC) meeting in Santa Barbara, California, one of the biggest points of contention concerned cyclists on State Street, the city’s main commercial corridor. Members of the committee had lots of questions. Why are bikers there? Are they using it as a thoroughfare, or are they shopping on State Street? Is it just tourists or locals?
Both MIG, Inc., who’s been contracted by the city to create designs for State Street, as well as the city, didn’t seem to have any answers. That’s why members of Strong Towns Santa Barbara, a new local nonprofit, set out to get them.
We wrote a short, five-question survey to administer to cyclists on the street; the results can be seen below. Questions included why they were there, with the ability to choose from a range of answers, including shopping, eating, sightseeing, because it’s safer than other streets, meeting with friends, or just passing through (participants could choose more than one). We then asked their age (in decade groups), their zip code, how often they bike there, and whether or not they want to see a dedicated space for bikes in the permanent designs.
Surveying location. Blue indicates the portion of State Street closed to cars.
We surveyed 131 cyclists and counted 965 bikes over 8.58 hours. Some of our results are surprising and challenge the claims made by some SSAC committee members, as well as those of the general public.
Number of bikes passing through the State/Cota intersection with approximate temperature (deg F). (Source: Kira Putsch.)
Before I share those results, let me give a disclaimer: our methods and survey were far from perfect. We only administered the survey over three days and counted bikes over four. The weather was different on those days, and the times we stood outside were different, too. We only surveyed/counted bikes at one location (the intersection of State and Cota). We also only gave the survey to cyclists, not all users of the street. We were also only able to survey a fraction of the people biking (approximately 16% of cyclists who passed on the three surveying days); many did not stop for us or too many came by at once. However, the goal was to understand the demographics of people who use State Street for biking, and in that, I believe we succeeded. In statistics, what we got is called a “representative survey,” meaning that it represents the views of the whole population, with room for margins of error. That means that in the future, the city should try to survey the population in more depth and over more time, though that doesn’t invalidate our results. I will also add that we are a completely volunteer organization, and I am grateful to Kira, Marie, and Tristen for standing outside for hours and flagging down cyclists for the survey.
With that out of the way, let me share our findings. See the image below.
Why Are You on State Street?
In the pie charts below, you can see the answer to perhaps the most important question we asked. On each day, shopping and eating made up between 26–32% of respondent activities. These activities correlate directly with spending money, so it’s safe to say that at least a third of people biking down State Street are adding to business revenue.
Why are you biking? Results per day. (Source: Kira Putsch.)
Another important takeaway is how many people are sightseeing and cruising. State Street is one of the most beautiful main streets in America, and tourists and locals alike are coming here to view the sights. That means that if bikes were diverted to Anacapa or Chapala streets, as some have suggested, bike volume would surely decrease.
Perhaps the most important result is how many people told us they’re biking on State because they feel that it’s safer than the alternatives. Many studies have shown that the greatest factor contributing to Americans not biking is a lack of safe infrastructure and a perception of danger. The new State Street, with its complete lack of deadly automobiles, is the ideal place for cyclists who would be afraid to ride elsewhere, once again providing a reason to not divert them to other streets.
These insights show that State Street is not being used as a “thoroughfare” as one of the SSAC members suggested. Cyclists on State Street are traveling to local businesses on the corridor, socializing, sightseeing, and feeling safe while they do so.
Where Are You From?
This question was meant to understand the balance of tourists vs. locals. It seems that most cyclists live within the same zip code as State Street, with the vast majority living in Santa Barbara.
Breakdown of bicyclists’ zip codes. (Source: Kira Putsch.)
How Old Are You?
Without getting too personal, we asked how old the cyclists were. The largest age group was 50–60, with ages 10–19 coming in second, and 30–40 not far behind. There were also cyclists under 10 and over 80. This spread shows that a variety of people are biking, not just teenagers.
Breakdown of bicyclists’ age groups. (Source: Kira Putsch.)
How Often?
Our last question found that a third of users bike on State Street every day, with frequency decreasing in percent of answers.
Frequency of biking on State Street. (Source: Kira Putsch.)
Conclusion
While our survey was far from perfect, the conclusions are pertinent to the conversation surrounding the future of State Street. A bike culture, which includes people of all ages doing various activities from hanging out to commuting, has developed along this beautiful street. In line with many other studies on the subject, we found that cyclists spend money at local shops. These cyclists feel safe here, which is the most important aspect of moving people from their cars to bikes. With about two bikes per minute on average, this bike phenomenon should be celebrated and worked into the permanent plan for State Street.
Reasons for biking: Utility vs. Pleasure. (Source: Kira Putsch.)
Why are you biking? Combined results over three days. (Source: Kira Putsch.)
In the next article in this series, I’ll address some of the concerns expressed by the SSAC, and explore how many of them can be addressed through smart urban design.
Sullivan Israel is a City and Regional Planning masters student, leader of the small-town nonprofit Strong Towns Santa Barbara, and urban planning enthusiast. You can read more of Israel’s writing over on Medium.
Biking advocates often argue that cities should add bike infrastructure because it'll reduce congestion. Reality is harder to predict. Here's why you should shift away from reducing congestion arguments and what you could focus on instead.